Why (Almost) Everyone Loves/Hates the 1911

The Colt Government Model of 1911 ranks with the Colt Peacemaker, Winchester 1873, and M-1 Garand as possibly the most iconic firearms in American history. The M1911 and later 1911 derivatives served as the standard US military sidearm for an astonishing 74 years. It saw combat in World War I, World War II, Korea, Vietnam, and other smaller wars until its eventual retirement in 1985. America’s most famous World War I hero, Medal of Honor winner Alvin York, used his 1911 to help him and his squad capture 132 German soldiers in a single day. York killed 25 more Germans in the process, several with his trusty Colt.

Alvin York and a Colt Government 1911
Medal of Honor winner Alvin York used a 1911 to capture 132 German soldiers in a single day, and killed 25 more, several with his Colt. (knoxnews.com and americanrifleman.org)

🔥 Check out the ultimate 1911 magazine compatibility guide. 

But the 1911 pistol took a longer path to immortality than the other guns on the list. In fact, the gun isn’t as universally loved as you might think. In the excellent video linked below, Chris Baker delves into the reasons for that and discusses the 1911s initial decline and later resurgence to the status it enjoys in today’s American gun culture.

Chris Baker of Lucky Gunner on why people love or hate the Colt 1911
Chris Baker of Lucky Gunner on why people love or hate the Colt 1911

A Browning Masterpiece but Mostly Ignored by Civilians

As most gun folks probably know, the 1911 was designed by John Moses Browning around the .45 ACP cartridge. It was a direct response to the poor performance of the Colt New Army revolver that was produced from 1892 to 1903. That revolver was chambered in the comparatively anemic .38 Long Colt, which proved less than effective in the Philippine Insurrection. The US Army wanted to return to the .45, and Browning’s answer was the 1911.

 John Moses Browning and the Colt 1911 pistol
In the first decade of the 20th century, the US Army wanted to return to the .45. The Colt Model of 1911 was John Moses Browning’s answer. (curtislowe.wordpress.com)

Chris notes that, while the 1911 was America’s military sidearm, the civilian gun world was dominated by revolvers. The police used revolvers, as did civilian competition shooters. When gun magazines wrote about handguns, they almost always wrote about revolvers. The real civilian shift away from revolvers only began in the 1980s and continued into the next decade. By then double-stack 9mm guns were widely available, the so-called “Wonder Nines.” The 1911 was “sort of a dinosaur at that point.”

Black and white image of American soldier with 1911
The 1911 served the US military across the globe for 74 years (weaponews.com)

Cooper Plants the Seed

When the US military switched to the Beretta M9 in 1985, the 1911 was in danger of fading from the view of all but military surplus collectors and a few dedicated defensive shooters being trained by retired Marine Lt. Colonel Jeff Cooper. Cooper was a prolific gun writer in the 1970s and 1980s. Focusing on defensive handgun shooting, he was also a strong advocate for the 1911.

Retired Marine Lt. Colonel Jeff Cooper aiming 1911 handgun
Retired Marine Lt. Colonel Jeff Cooper was a prolific gun writer and advocate for the 1911 as a defensive pistol. (dailycaller.com)

In 1976, Cooper established a scenario-based competition pistol league that eventually became the United States Practical Shooting Association (USPSA). That same year, Cooper founded Gunsite Academy in Arizona, where he began training defensive shooting skills to civilians. The 1911 featured heavily both at Gunsite and in USPSA competitions. But, at that point, there wasn’t much to choose from when it came to 1911s. Colt was the only manufacturer, with the Gold Cup National Match being the top of the line.

As competitive shooters began looking for ways to improve their guns, a new industry emerged offering custom upgrades, like an extended beavertail, beveled mag well, or an enhanced hammer spur for a competitive edge. Many of those companies began making their own 1911s with those upgrades as standard features. The popularity of those guns eventually spread to firearms enthusiasts in general.

Jeff Cooper, founder of Gunsite Academy
Cooper founded Gunsite Academy in 1976 and created the shooting league that would become the USPSA. (gunsite.com)

But, by the early 1990s, the 1911 was in decline thanks to the popularity of the double stack 9mm guns. Companies like Beretta, Sig Sauer, and Glock were offering high-quality products with higher capacity and better ergonomics. It didn’t help that the Beretta 92, in particular, was featured prominently in hit movie franchises like Die Hard and Lethal Weapon (we will not discuss the infamous “Glock 7”). It seemed the 1911 really might fade away this time…until The Man stepped in.

Clinton, Biden, and Feinstein Save the 1911

1994 saw the passage of the infamous Crime Bill pushed by then-President Bill Clinton, then-Senator Joe Biden, and gun grabber extraordinaire Senator Dianne Feinstein. Included in that onerous piece of legislation was the “Assault Weapons” Ban, which limited magazine capacity across the board to ten rounds. Suddenly, the 9mm guns didn’t carry that much more ammo, and many gun owners decided that if they were limited in capacity, they would carry bigger rounds. The .45 ACP 1911 was back, baby.

Colt 1911 advertisement and models
Colt offered few options into the 1980s, when a custom 1911 industry sprang up around competitive shooting (Lucky Gunner YouTube)

Popularity soared and continues to this day. Dozens of companies now make 1911s in all sizes, from full to subcompact, single and double stack, and in multiple calibers. Chris—fairly, I think—points out that some of these guns are barely 1911s due to their size and features. He mentions the diminutive Sig Sauer P238, the Wilson Combat EDC-9, and some double-stack 2011 guns. Not that those are bad guns or anything. But they have clearly veered off the main 1911 path. Even though the .45 ACP’s popularity has waned thanks to cost and the increased performance of the 9mm cartridge, the sheer variety of 1911s has kept John Browning’s design in the game.

competitive shooter aiming 1911
Competitive shooters were vital to the survival of the 1911 in the civilian market in the 1970s and 1980s. (gundigest.com)

So, Why Do Some People Dislike the 1911?

Great question, and Chris has some answers. Let’s hit those real quick:

  • 1911s are big and heavy in relation to their limited capacity (standard 7 or 8 plus 1)
  • Some people don’t like the grip and/or the thumb safeties
  • Even a cheap 1911 costs about the same as a basic polymer striker-fired gun
  • They generally aren’t as reliable as those polymer guns
  • The more affordable 1911s generally aren’t as reliable as expensive ones

Now, I’ll admit that the last one shouldn’t necessarily count. It’s normal for more expensive guns to work better than budget guns. At least, that’s how it’s supposed to work. But there are striker-fired polymer guns available at competitive prices that will go bang every time with just a little maintenance. Chris points out that if you plan to use a 1911 in a defensive capacity, you better spend at least $1000 to $1500. There are quality polymer guns available for half that. And that $1500 gun only gets you a mid-range 1911.

stovepipe malfunction
Chris notes that even the best 1911s require more maintenance than the average modern polymer striker-fired handguns. (gunmagwarehouse.com)

Not to mention that your money doesn’t always guarantee quality. Some manufacturers make pretty guns and sell them for a premium, but they aren’t that great on the inside. Even top-shelf 1911s require more maintenance than a basic Glock or Sig. Chris notes that the further you get from the original 1911 size and caliber, the truer that becomes. He advises sticking with a five-inch barreled 1911 chambered in .45 ACP or a Commander size, which is good in .45 or 9mm. When the barrel length drops below four inches, that’s where reliability really drops off, and you have to start paying attention to things like recoil spring weight and ammo compatibility.

1911s can be very reliable and they can be affordable, but they are rarely both. For people used to paying 500 bucks for a polymer gun that can go 5,000 rounds between cleanings, you can see where the 1911’s fussiness can be a downside.

Why Do Some People Like, or Even Love the 1911?

Compared to the 1970s, we have almost unlimited options for quality handguns. Chris believes modern handguns can do everything better and less expensively than the 1911, with two exceptions. First, the 1911 is still the gold standard for a nice trigger on a handgun. 1911 triggers tend to be light with a very short length of travel. They also slide directly to the rear with no levering or pivot motion, so the trigger stays in contact with the same part of the finger throughout the entire trigger press.

Nighthawk Custom 70 series
Today’s market is full of premium 1911 offerings, like these Nighthawk Custom 70 Series guns (Lucky Gunner YouTube)

To be fair, there are some cheap 1911s with terrible triggers, but they are a distinct minority. Most are at least pretty good. The trigger makes the 1911 easy to shoot quickly and effectively, and it’s extremely forgiving of imperfect trigger control techniques.

The trigger does, however, come with some liability. A light trigger is not always desirable, and Chris believes that only experienced shooters who practice a lot and know how to manage the trigger should choose a 1911 as a carry gun. They are very unforgiving of even small mistakes in safe gun handling.

The other advantage of the 1911 is pride of ownership. Chris says, “It’s really gratifying to own a well-made machine that also looks like a really well-made machine.” That’s especially true if it’s been in the hands of a highly skilled craftsman or gunsmith who has customized it to your exact specifications. “A gun like that just compels you to take it out to the range and shoot it, and carry it, and show it to your friends.”

There are very few new semi-automatic pistols you can buy today that evoke that kind of pride of ownership that you get from a well-made 1911. The industry has responded to that lack by offering ways to individualize polymer pistols, but Chris thinks most of those mods are “pretty lame.” No matter what you do with it, a Glock still looks like a Glock. As Chris says, “It’s just not the same as a shiny chunk of polished steel and wood.”

Wilson Combat custom
Even tricked-out polymer pistols just aren’t the same as a “shiny chunk of polished wood and steel,” as this Wilson Combat custom 1911 demonstrates. (wilsoncombat.com)

Even an off-the-shelf 1911 can have that “wow factor” that you can’t get from a more modern pistol. Chris notes that if you think of your gun primarily as a tool, you might think such things are frivolous, and you’re likely correct to a certain extent. But most folks aren’t driven by pure logic.

It can be a good thing to get some enjoyment from your defensive firearms because it can help motivate you to practice with it more. It can, however, go the other way. We can like it so much that we can get delusional about its capabilities but it’s good to have some level of affection for your defensive gun for whatever reason. A nice 1911 lends itself to that admirably.

So, what do you think? Love the 1911? Hate it? Don’t care? Let us know why in the comments.

William "Bucky" Lawson is a self-described "typical Appalachian-American gun enthusiast". He is a military historian specializing in World War II and has written a few things, as he says, "here and there". A featured contributor for Strategy & Tactics, he likes dogs, range time, and a good cigar - preferably with an Old Fashioned that has an extra orange slice.


Sign Up for Newsletter

Let us know what topics you would be interested:
© 2024 GunMag Warehouse. All Rights Reserved.
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap