How Does the New M&P Shield Plus (Double) Stack Up?

There’s a new Smith & Wesson Shield: The M&P Shield Plus. The latest version of the venerable 9mm micro-compact has an advantage over its predecessors—a significant increase in capacity. The earlier versions of the smallest 9mm Shield held 7 rounds in its flush-fit magazine, but this new one begins with 10 rounds in the mag. And the extended mag holds 13.

The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus. The Plus is the real news, here.
The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus. The Plus is the real news, here.

That may be the most noticeable difference for those who know the older gun. And it isn’t insignificant. Imagine you could have a car that looks exactly like your current car but gets almost twice the gas mileage. Would you make the switch?

Magazine capacity isn’t the same as gas mileage. I tend to spend more on ammo when I’ve got magazines with increased capacity. I can’t leave rounds in the mag—just doesn’t feel right—so I shoot until they’re empty. A more apt metaphor would be a car with a much bigger gas tank.

The M&P Shield Plus is big enough to hold and small enough to be concealed easily.
The M&P Shield Plus is big enough to hold and small enough to be concealed easily.

The capacity, no matter how you look at it, is the big story here. The Shield, a tremendously popular EDC gun and a popular choice for a backup gun for many, now holds more rounds. Smith could have stopped right there and made news with this gun.

The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus. Nice capacity.
The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus. Nice capacity.

How did they increase the Shield’s capacity?

The grip is a bit wider. By my measurements, the M&P Shield Plus is about 1/10 of an inch wider. It feels more ovoid in shape. I’ve got big hands, so I’m not bothered by the extra size. In fact, I can’t really notice it unless it is side-by-side with an original.

M&P Shield Plus grip
The grip is slightly larger than that of the original, but I have trouble feeling the increase.

My 13-year-old son, though, picked it up and said “this is much wider.” So there you go. He’s about 5’7″. I’m 6’4″. He can feel the size. I can’t.

S&W M&P Shield Plus magazine gif
Why are there fired rounds in the magazine? Don’t ask. It is still a top-notch illustration.

I can marvel at the interior of the grip, though. That’s where much of the strategic reduction happened. The magazine is noticeably boxy at the shoulders, where the two lines of ammo become one, and the M&P Shield Plus had to make room for it somehow.

And the mags are still very well built. They’re steel and laser welded.

The interior walls of the new Shield Plus are thin.
The interior walls of the new Shield are thin. Hard to take a good image of the inside of the mag.

What else did Smith do to the Shield?

There are two other big changes to the gun. The first is the grip texture. Smith has softened the texture just a bit. It looks like there was a very jagged pattern of micro pyramids that have been hit with just enough heat to round off the peaks. The new texture is supposed to be slightly easier on the hands and much easier on clothing and skin for those who carry it every day.

M&P Shield Plus grip texture. Note the texture on the mag-release button, too.
The new grip texture. Note the texture on the mag-release button, too. Just enough to be meaningful.

While I am a fan of the increased capacity of the M&P Shield Plus, I’m not so enamored with the grip texture. I’ve only had this gun for a week, but I’ve taken it to the range twice. Both times, the weather was just hot enough for me to break a sweat when I was moving. And it gets a bit slick.

The trigger on the new Shield Plus has a flat face. It feels fantastic.
The trigger on the new Shield has a flat face. It feels fantastic.

I can hold an older Shield almost completely flat. This newer version is slightly harder to hold down. The texture doesn’t bite into my skin as I’d like. If I’m even slightly sweaty, muzzle-flip becomes harder to control.

Part of this comes from the lack of texture on the frame. One of the many things that Smith is missing is texture above the trigger well and on the front of the frame. Is that a deal-breaker for a gun like this? Hardly—but it is something you need to train around.

The other change

The M&P Shield Plus also has a flat-faced trigger. This one, like the capacity, is kickass.

S&W M&P Shield Plus flat faced trigger.









I really like the trigger on this gun—it functions flawlessly. There’s a slight take-up and a clean break. The reset is reasonable for an EDC gun and easy enough to feel in rapid-fire.

The trigger breaks at a comfortable 6+ pounds. That’s reasonable for accurate shot placement and stout enough that I’m not likely to pull without an intentional movement.

Sights and such

There are ways that the Shield has always been a great EDC gun, and the new version is no different. The mag-release button on this gun is big enough to find and use without having to look at the grip. It isn’t so big that you will accidentally press it when you grip the pistol, but it isn’t small either. And the texture there is nice both aesthetically and functionally.

The M&P Shield Plus slide release.
The slide release.

The slide release is much harder to use. There’s a slight bump in the steel, but it is still much easier to sling-shot this one closed during a mag change. You can hit that button, but it takes some serious muscle to drop the slide.

Like the other Shield pistols, take-down couldn’t be easier. You can release this lever easily and you don’t have to pull the trigger to get the slide off. This is a welcome feature—one that is meant to prevent accidents.

The Standard Shield Plus version has white 3-dot sights. The Performance Center version offers other options.
The Standard version has white 3-dot sights. The Performance Center version offers other options. Note the odd bit of texture on the rear of the slide. Don’t put your thumb there.

The sights, though. Back when the Honor Guard took on the Shield, one of the many things that Honor Defense got right was the sights. There’s no good reason to have a sloped ramp on the front of your rear sight. Not one. Is that so you can be sloppy when you shove it into a holster?

The M&P Shield Plus front sight is drift adjustable, as is the rear.
The front sight is drift adjustable, as is the rear.

With a ledge on that edge of the sight, the gun can be racked one-handed much more easily. Hook that ledge on anything, even your holster, and push. That’s it.

The sights on the M&P Shield Plus aren’t bad—they’re just not great.

But there’s a Performance Center option that offers several other upgrades, and sights are the first thing I’d fix.

Shooting the M&P Shield Plus

A disclaimer. When I shoot slow and steady, I can shoot accurately. With subcompact 9mms and the urgency I force into concealed carry drills, I tend to pull consecutive shots left of center.

25 feet, target shot group from a full 10 round Shield Plus magazine.
25 feet, a full 10 round magazine from the Shield Plus.

With the M&P Shield Plus, I had to slow down a bit to get the dead-nuts accuracy I was looking for. But it delivered. This is from 25 feet. That’s not bad for me and this size gun. I was really impressed, actually, with how easy it was for me to punch out the center.

Notice how my support hand is slipping from the frame.
Notice how my support hand is slipping from the frame.

I’m a big proponent of training. And this is why. I have a harder time holding down this gun than I do other subcompact 9mms. Even when I have a solid grip on the gun, it wants to kick up more than others this size.

Shield Plus recoil with a younger shooter's hands. There's just not much for the support hand to connect to.
The same look from a much-younger shooter. There’s just not much for the support hand to connect to.

And here you can see the same in my son’s hands. The Shield Plus surprised him. This was actually his first shot with it, and he thought he had it held down.

Practice getting back on target for that second and third shot, and run them fast.
Practice getting back on target for that second and third shot, and run them fast.

After a few rounds, though, you’ll get the feel for what it takes. The gun is controllable. We all need regular practice with our grip—and the Shield Plus will remind you of that if you get lax.

These guns are not meant to be fun-guns or plinkers. They’re designed for EDC. I can see what Smith was doing with softening the grip texture. It is what it is.

As for holsters, I haven’t had the chance to check direct compatibility between the new version and the older ones. I’d think it should fit 2.0 holsters with no problem, or anything forgiving and leather.

Urban Carry holster.
The only holster I had on hand that fit was this one from Urban Carry.

Wrapping up

The M&P Shield Plus has an MSRP of $553. Retail, even in this market, is lower. And yes—I did buy this one outright. As a gun reviewer, I typically get guns loaned to me for review purposes, but I didn’t this time. I bought this two days after Smith announced the new gun, and my FFL had several in stock.

The price-tag may be enough to keep some folks away. It puts the new Shield out of reach for some, but it is consistent with S & W’s pricing. And the gun is a welcome addition to a growing field of sub-compact 9mms with robust capacity. Competition keeps these companies honest.

And there are options for those who want to take this gun to the next level. As I mentioned above, the Performance Center upgrades are available. For those who want to run red dots, that may be a good place to start.

David Higginbotham is a writer and editor who specializes in everyday carry. David is a former backcountry guide in the Sangre de Cristo Mountains and Boundary Waters Canoe Area who was a college professor for 20 years. He ultimately left behind the academy for a more practical profession in the firearms industry and was (among other editorial positions) the Managing Editor for a nascent Mag Life blog. In that Higginbotham helped establish The Maglife's tone and secure its early success. Though he went on to an even more practical firearms industry profession still, he continues to contribute articles and op-eds as time and life allow.

Sign Up for Newsletter

Let us know what topics you would be interested:
© 2024 GunMag Warehouse. All Rights Reserved.
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap