Lessons and Lore from Elmer Keith

I’ve been what most would classify as a ‘gun nut’ since about the age of 12. I truly enjoy shooting anything that has a trigger and goes “Bang,” whether it’s chambered in .17 caliber or .50 caliber, or anything in between. Along the way, my tastes and interests have drifted towards the tactical and self-defense fields, which is why I conduct training in those areas. One thing I’ve learned on my journey is that there is very little that is new and innovative. The old saying, “If you want to learn something new, read an old book,” holds very true in the firearms field.

Elmer Keith shooting a pair of .44 Magnum revolvers
The Grand Old Man himself, shooting a pair of his .44 Magnum revolvers, along with the pipe and big Stetson hat that made him instantly recognizable to fans around the world. (Photo source: Public Domain.)

So, what’s this got to do with some guy named Elmer? For those of you who are just joining us, this “Elmer” guy is Elmer Keith, known to some as the Sage of Salmon, Idaho, and Dean of American Gunwriters to others. He was a cowboy, hunter, packer, guide, shooter, prolific experimenter, and gun writer during most of the 20th century. He was the driving force behind the creation of the .44 Magnum, the .338 Winchester Magnum, the Winchester Model 70 bolt action rifle, the .41 Magnum, a style of bullet that bears his name to this day, and countless other things during his lifetime. He was born in 1899, during an era the likes of which we’ll never see again. His mentors were those men who fought on the frontier and during the Civil War, men who knew more about living and dying with the gun than most do today.

.357 and .44 cartridges
Elmer was directly responsible for the development of many firearms-related things in his life, including his heavy bullets in .357 and .44, shown here. His wildcat cartridge experiments eventually led to the creation of the .338 Winchester Magnum rifle cartridge, which became one of his favorites.

In the tactical and self-defense training sectors today, there is a lot of talk about shooting on the move, shooting at multiple targets (since bad guys usually run in packs,) point shooting, shooting at close and long range, and generally “being one with the gun.” The way it’s read, you’d think that this is all some new knowledge that’s just been discovered in the last 20 years or so since we had a couple of big shooting wars in that time. Well, I hate to tell you, but it’s all been said before, and Elmer said it.

In 1955 Elmer Keith wrote the classic shooting book, “Sixguns by Keith.” It was more or less a treatise on all things having to do with shooting the handgun, from choosing the right handgun for the job, learning to shoot it, competition, gunfighting, quick draw, point shooting, shooting at long range, holsters, modifying the handgun, and choosing the right cartridge. It was literally a one-stop shop for the new pistol shooter. Elmer Keith was not the last word by any means, but he was smart enough to learn from others the skills needed to stay alive in a dangerous world. He was able to combine that with his own vast amount of personal experience and to put it into words.

Let’s take a look at a few things Elmer talked about almost 60 years ago, and how they apply today.

Sixguns by Elmer Keith
The classic treatise on all things shooting, “Sixguns by Keith,” along with the authors 29-3 and 6 rounds of .44 Magnum, loaded with the 250gr Keith bullet.

Elmer Keith on Learning the Gun

More time is required to master the handgun than any other type of firearm. To become an expert shot, one must live with the gun.  Only by constant use and practice can one acquire a thorough mastery of the short gun. You must work and play with it, eat with it, sleep with it and shoot it every day, until it becomes a part of you and you handle it surely and easily as you would your fork and knife at the table. 

-…good shots are not born; they are made by careful conscientious training.  The best shots practice daily.

Every day we see new shooters enter the gun world, and this is no doubt a good thing.  However, many of them seem to think that they can buy proficiency if they just get the right gun, shoot the right ammo, or watch the right DVD. A couple of times at the range, a YouTube video, and a good night’s sleep, and they should be good to go, right? The truth is, you have to do the work. The best shooters in the world work at it every day, and many of them are training for a mere trophy. The new shooter, who is buying the gun to protect the lives of themselves or their loved ones, has much more at stake. So, why don’t they train just as much, if not more? Because it’s hard and requires dedication, and one doesn’t get the instant results that most are accustomed to in modern life. Unfortunately, there’s no other way. Whether it’s with a full-size gun, or a .22, you have to get in the trigger time.

four handguns matched with ammo
No matter what gun you use, Elmer believed you have to get out and shoot to become better. There’s no substitute for trigger time!

On Backup Guns

These pocket guns are a valuable addition to the officer’s armament when he does pack a heavy holster gun. He may lose it in a scrimmage and also may have some thug get the drop on him and disarm him. Then the little hidden pocket gun may prove a life-saver. 

While there are a lot of us who advocate the backup gun for law enforcement and civilian use, for a long period of time it was thought that if you had a second gun, you were guilty of poor peace officering, you were going to use it as a ‘throw-down’ in an accidental shooting, or you were just a paranoid loon.  Luckily these attitudes have changed greatly, but there are still a lot of people who think that carrying a second or backup gun is somehow crazy. Yet, even six decades ago, the smart people were doing it. If you carry a gun, you probably need to carry two.

On Quick Draw and Getting the Gun Into Action

In practicing quick draw, avoid all strained or unnatural positions. Stand loosely but with the weight well balanced on both feet, and if anything, lean into your target. In combat it is a good thing to move after the first shot and get down as low as possible so you will afford a smaller target for your adversary’s fire. 

-One should be able to throw a slug from any position he may be in, sitting, standing or lying down. After the first shot is time to move if necessary. In any gunfight in the dark, always move after or with every shot and change position as much as possible. 

-After one has practiced getting the gun into action in a fraction of a second, enough years, all that is needed to start the fireworks is the realization of immediately necessity.  The subconscious mind takes over and the shooting starts before another thought can register.

 Hollywood would have you believe that the classic ‘gunfighters crouch,’ with the body locked up and the shooter’s hand formed in a rigid claw above the gun is how it’s done. We know now that one moves much faster when the muscles are relaxed. Also, we have taught for a long time to move after you start shooting, or move and shoot at the same time. If you stand in place, you’re probably going to die there, as well.  Shoot and move is the name of the game.

We don’t always know where the fight will come from, so you need to be able to draw and shoot from unconventional positions, such as sitting inside our car or behind a desk, or shooting from the ground after being knocked down in a fight. A lot of instructors today like to think that this kind of training is somehow revolutionary; it seems arrogant to think that somehow no one in the last 200 years or so managed to come up with the same thing!

If you do the work long enough, consistently enough, you reach a state of ‘unconscious competence,’ where you don’t have to think about the act, it just happens. This leaves your mind free to deal with other things that happen in a fight.  If you study the old-time gunmen, you’ll find that they had already made the decision to fight long before the fight started. If you want to claim the title of ‘gunman’ and wear it proudly, then you must work at it.

Elmer Keith on Gunfighting and Personal Defense

-Gun fighting is nasty business, but as long as we have a criminal element, or nations bent on mastery of the world, it will be necessary. The best defense against either is a trained citizenry of gun fighters who will keep and carry on the traditions of this great country for posterity.

Smith & Wesson Model 29 .44 Magnum
The gun Elmer Keith is most recognized for, the Smith & Wesson Model 29 .44 Magnum. This is a 4” 29-3, nickel plated with stag grips and Tyler T-Grip adaptor, with a Loaded Sourdough holster from Simply Rugged.

This hasn’t changed a whole lot in almost 60 years.  We still have enemies, foreign and domestic, that want to do us harm at all costs.  Whether it be the crackhead trying to score his next fix, or a government entity run amok, a well-trained and armed people cannot be subjugated, nor intimidated.  It is up to every able-bodied man and woman to become sufficiently trained in the use of arms and pass it on to the next generation.  Only in that way will our children, and our children’s children, remain free.

Elmer Keith wasn’t the end-all to be all; he was just a man, but his advice on these subjects still passes the common sense test. Go back and read an old book sometime, written before the time of internet videos, training DVDs and even shooting schools. Luckily for us, “Sixguns” is back in print from Wolfe Publishing, and belongs on the shelf of every serious shooter. Pick it up, and read it.  You just might learn something new.

Steve Collins is a firearms and tactics instructor with over 25 years of teaching military, security and civilian personnel.  He spent 17 years on active duty with the US Army and served during Operation Desert Shield/Desert Storm and Operation Iraqi Freedom.  He has been head of Personal Security Details for field grade and General Officers during his time overseas.  He was also a shooter/instructor with the US Army Marksmanship Unit, competing in action pistol matches and training deploying military personnel in the combat use of the rifle and pistol.  While assigned to the Basic Officers Leaders Course at Fort Benning, GA, he was the primary instructor for Advanced Rifle Marksmanship, and was responsible for training over 400 newly commissioned lieutenants during his time there. He holds instructor certifications from the US Army and the National Rifle Association, and has conducted training classes in Alabama, Illinois, Washington, and Missouri. Steve began shooting in rifle competition when he was 12 years old, competition pistol at 15, and has won numerous awards since. When he's not shooting or writing, Steve spends his time chasing chickens, annoying his wife of 25 years, and playing with his grandkids on their compound in SW Missouri.

Sign Up for Newsletter

Let us know what topics you would be interested:
© 2024 GunMag Warehouse. All Rights Reserved.
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap